I honestly do. While the hero-worship aspect of athletics might confuse me, I really do understand the appeal of, the fun, and camaraderie that can come from sports fandom. And I certainly don't delight in being a joykill. But the fact is, as some aspects of the culture and policies of the sport and (in the NFL and colleges) currently stand, I simply cannot bring myself to enjoy it.
There are several reasons, but I'm going to tell you about two of them more in-depth:
1) The incredibly prevalent instance of brain damage and lifelong injury amongst former players. 87 of 91 deceased NFL players have tested positive for the degenerative brain disease CTE, which is known to cause severe depression, a life time of severe headaches, early-onset dementia, and can be misdiagnosed as ALS. It's very difficult for me to understand how we can cheer the hard hits and revel in the brutal nature of the game when we have the technology now to see exactly it's irreparably damaging the bodies and the lives of those playing it-- not to mention its effects on the lives of their loved ones. Is our entertainment that important?
Until the league starts taking serious steps (such as rule changes, comprehensive research on the risks, and medical care for retired players) to fix this horrifying reality, I won't be able to watch a game without a cringing face and a hurting heart.
2) The culture of excusing violence against women. While domestic violence and sexual assault are certainly horrifyingly widespread across the country, they do seem to be particularly endemic and tolerated within the world of football. I *personally* know of multiple girls who were raped and abused by college football players at major universities, and the players almost always go unpunished. And I'm not just talking "he said, she said"-- I'm talking cases where there were videos, photographic evidence of bruises, police reports, and rape kits. Even then, the universities side with the players at the expense of the victims.
They continue to recruit players who are *known* to be violence, known to have assaulted, and who go on to assault again. I can list multiple recent example of this from Baylor alone: Sam Ukwuachu, Tevin Elliot (who had a previous sexual misconduct charge and went on to be accused by SIX women of sexual assault at Baylor), and another player who I can't name for the sake of privacy for his victim, who's a friend of mine. And this pattern is far from new. Check out this partial list of known sexual assault cases involving football players at major universities, and the outcomes of the cases. Spoiler alert: it doesn't seem to go well for the victims. I can't help but wonder how it feels for the hundreds, if not thousands of women, who have to watch as hundreds of thousands of people cheer for their attackers-- how it feels to have their trauma shoved back in their faces as the ones who tortured them are lauded as heroes.
Would schools be so passionate about "second chances", about "benefit of the doubt" (for the players rather than for the women) if these men weren't football players? Almost certainly not. Would these girls have been silenced, asked by coaching staff not to report (what happened to my friend), and denied the chance to heal? Not as likely. Because universities and the NFL continue to show that players that could help them win games and thus make money are more important to them than the safety and wellbeing of women. And by continuing to tune into the games, buy tickets, buy merchandise, voting with their dollars instead of making a fuss, fans continue to show that they do, too.
After the Ray Rice incident, the NFL made a bit of hoopla and started the "No More" campaign-- but it turns out that's all talk and doesn't even purport to do anything.
While they say they'd never tolerate violence or silence victims, stories from the actual women say otherwise-- they say that team personal and police tell them to keep quiet.
They say that they'd never harbor abusers, but in 2012, a reporter found that 21 out of 32 NFL teams employed at least one player with a domestic abuse or sexual assault charge *in that same year alone*.
The continue to draft players with known histories of violence, even when those players were kicked off of college teams, even when there are multiple witnesses who saw a beating take place, even when there were graphic pictures of a woman's bruised and bloodied body in police reports. They show with their actions that they do not care if a player has hit or raped a woman.
As it starts, football culture and rape culture are intertwined. This doesn't have to be the case though. As writer Jessica Luther says in her piece on the overlap of football culture and rape culture,
I can imagine a football culture that does not work this way. It would involve including a lot more women in all kinds of roles within teams, university athletic departments, and league administrations. It would include mandatory annual rape prevention training focused on teaching consent and empathy for the victim. (That we don’t teach these things already was a takeaway from the Steubenville trial.) It would ban the use of college women in recruitment, and it would treat women as regular fans of football.In the end, whether or not Jameis Winston is guilty,
we knowhe is deeply invested in a football culture that is incredibly problematic, especially where it intersects with rape culture. Football culture clouds our ability to see him as anything other than a famous kid with a nice-guy persona and amazing athletic skills. Rape culture demands that we mistrust the victim, question her credibility, and try to poke holes in her story. It creates this familiar narrative in which people who have invested their own hopes and dreams in Winston claim his innocence immediately and refuse to hear anything else.No matter what happens in the Winston case, I do know this: Money will continue to flow, and games will be won. Football will march on and over whatever bodies it must. And many will cheer it on as it does.
Until teams start to follow through on their promises to protect victims instead of harboring rapists and abusers, I can't bring myself to be one of those cheering.
Look, I don't think that liking football makes you a terrible person who doesn't have morals. I also know that there are plenty of players and personnel and maybe even fans who do care deeply about these issues. But these are systemic issues that aren't going to change without decisive effort, and that effort will not come until the fans, those who make football the insanely profitable beast that it is, start speaking out with their voices and dollars. If you care about the players, their loved ones, or the women who've been victimized, I highly encourage you to click on some of the above links, do some research, and start using your voice.
May we become a culture who values human lives and wellbeing over entertainment and dollars.






